New York Yankees vs. Athletics Betting Splits — May 31, 2026

91% of bets are on Over 9.5 in New York Yankees at Athletics — heavy public lean on a May 31, 2026 matchup.

Splits at the latest snapshot

Market Side Bet % Money % Odds
Moneyline New York Yankees 91% 95% -154
Athletics 9% 5% +135
Run line New York Yankees -1.5 95% 98% +102
Athletics +1.5 5% 2% -119
Total Over 9.5 91% 90% -110
Under 9.5 9% 10% -118

What the data says

New York Yankees at Athletics is one of the slate's lopsided public plays. 91% of the bet count on the totals market is sitting on Over 9.5 — the kind of one-way lean that usually shows up on a name-brand team in a high-profile primetime slot, not a coin-flip matchup.

The money side tells a slightly different story: 90% of dollars on Over 9.5 versus 91% of tickets. That's a small gap by itself, but in the context of a 90%+ public bet count, even a few points of money lag suggests the average bet on Under 9.5 is materially larger. Books price these games knowing the public is coming — the line builds in the lean — which is why heavy public favorites historically underperform their implied win rate against the spread.

None of this is a pick. It's the snapshot of how money is landing on this game right now. See how we calculate splits →.

Tonight's strongest MLB plays — locked.

Our advanced model rates every MLB game by expected value, using thousands of historical splits as the backbone. Tonight's highest-EV picks are reserved for subscribers.

Advanced Pick #1 — +EV — ▒▒▒▒▒▒▒ · ▒▒▒▒▒▒▒ Moneyline
Advanced Pick #2 — +EV — ▒▒▒▒▒▒▒ · ▒▒▒▒▒▒▒ Run Line
Advanced Pick #3 — +EV — ▒▒▒▒▒▒▒ · ▒▒▒▒▒▒▒ Total
Unlock advanced EV picks →

Want a free look? See tonight's biggest splits →

Related

Frequently asked questions

How does Fade the Public Analytics calculate splits?

We aggregate publicly reported sportsbook handle on a sub-hourly cadence. See our methodology page for the full breakdown.

Are these picks or just data?

These are data displays. We don't issue picks. Use the splits to inform your own bets — and bet responsibly.

When does the public usually win?

Public favorites still win plenty of games — they are usually the better team. Where the public underperforms is against the spread on big-name teams in nationally televised games.

What is the difference between bet% and money%?

Bet% is the share of tickets wagered on a side. Money% is the share of dollars. They diverge when one side draws bigger bets per ticket than the other.

Should I bet on Over 9.5 tonight?

We don't issue picks. The splits show what the public and the money are doing — use them to inform your own read of the game.

What does a heavy public lean mean?

When 70%+ of bets land on one side, the line builds in some of that lean — so the public favorite is rarely a value bet, even when it's the better team. Watch where the money lands relative to the bet count. See our methodology →

How we track public bets and money — see our methodology →

Last updated: May 31, 2026 at 5:13 AM UTC

See tonight's biggest MLB splits — free.

Every game on the slate, ranked by public-vs-money divergence. Splits-based top opportunities, updated continuously. No signup, no paywall.

See all of tonight's splits →

Or unlock our advanced EV picks →